Flatbush Community Gathers to Protest Eviction of Octogenarian Tenant

State Senator Jesse Hamilton, Ms. Joy P. Noel, Estefania Trujillo of the Flatbush Tenant Coalition, City Councilmember Jumaane Williams and members of the local community stood together to demand Ms. Noel’s return to her apartment after an allegedly illegal eviction. (Paul Stremple/BKLYNER)

FLATBUSH DITMAS PARK – When Ms. Joy P. Noel came back to New York after seeking medical treatment abroad, the 80-something year old grandmother was homeless. She’d been evicted from her apartment at the Ditmas Arms, which she had called home for more than 20 years, and her belongings had been packed up and put in storage—all without her knowing.

This morning, members of the Flatbush Tenant Coalition gathered with local political leaders, community organizers and tenants to demand Ms. Noel’s reinstatement in her apartment and call for an end to predatory tactics by landlords to wrongfully evict tenants. More than 50 people gathered in the lobby of Ms. Noel’s building for the press conference.

According to Ms. Noel and the Flatbush Tenant Coalition, she was evicted through a holdover case, a process used to evict a tenant for reasons other than non-payment of rent. However, the legal notices sent to Ms. Noel, who lives in the 11226 zip code, were addressed incorrectly—her name misspelled as “Nole” and the zip 11215—so she never received them.

Bklyner reporting is supported by our subscribers and:

Unaware of the legal proceedings against her, Ms. Noel didn’t appear in housing court, and lost her case.

The Carnegie Management company, which manages the building at 585 East 21st Street, was previously involved in an illegal eviction case in Williamsburg. Tenants in Ms. Noel’s building said that the company has offered to buy them out, and has even shut off gas to the building since February.

“They’re not only trying to make money,” said Ms. Noel, “they’re jeopardizing the lives of tenants.”

New York State Senator Jesse Hamilton spoke to those gathered, calling Ms Noel’s eviction “unconscionable” and decrying the practice of landlords targeting buildings with senior residents and using legal means and weak rent laws to evict them, often through campaigns of harassment and intimidation.

“Carnegie Management, we’re watching you, we’re coming after you,” he said, “You will no longer come after our seniors—shame on your Carnegie Management!”

City Coucilmember Jumaane Williams, who has long fought for tenant’s rights, called the eviction of Ms. Noel an “egregious, malicious” act by “disgusting landlords” that was “all about greed.”

Williams said the situation was a failure of Governor Cuomo’s tenure and weak rent laws that allow rent hikes through Major Capital Improvements—which are often unnecessary.

The Councilmember, who is the chair of the Council’s Committee on Housing and Buildings, cited a recent case in which landlords paid more than $100,000 in fines for tenant harassment, and told those gathered that he would encourage State Attorney General Schneiderman to look into Carnegie Management for tenant harassment as well.

“It’s criminal and they deserve to be in jail,” said Williams.

Neither State Senator Hamilton nor Councilmember Williams represent the district in which Ms. Noel resides, but felt strongly enough about the case to speak today.

Ms. Noel confronts Jacob Friedman, Management Operations Director for 585 E 21st St, over her eviction, along with Councilmember Jumaane Williams (Paul Stremple/BKLYNER)

Halfway through the press conference, Jacob Friedman, the Management Operations Director for the property, showed up. The crowd gathered around him as he explained that Ms. Noel had been evicted for failure to pay rent, citing a balance of $75,000.

Councilmember Williams quickly informed the man that a holdover case, like the one used to evict Ms. Noel, is explicitly not about money, but is an eviction for other reasons. Friedman demurred, stating that he was not a lawyer nor involved in the eviction process.

Friedman did confirm that the gas in the building had been shut off, but refused to go into detail as to why. Cries of “shame” from those gathered drowned out some of what the man was trying to say.

City Councilmember Mathieu Eugene, who represents District 40 and Ms. Noel, showed up late in the press conference and left quickly without speaking, after about 5 minutes. State Senator Parker, who represents the district as well, was not present.

Josue Pierre, District leader from the 42nd Assembly District, brought a message of solidarity with Ms. Noel. “You can tell a lot about a society by the way we treat our seniors,” said Pierre. “Let this not be a precedent, let this not be allowed.”

In the meantime, the Flatbush Tenant Coalition has set up a fundraising page to help Ms. Noel raise money to recover her belongings from storage before they’re auctioned off on November 20.

Despite the event’s focus on her plight, Ms. Noel made a strong statement about the greater need for justice, calling on “everyone who came and everyone you know” to fight for tenants rights.

“We are here today not for Joy P. Noel,” she said, “but for justice in our community.”

This story is free to read thanks to the generous support from readers like you. To support independent local journalism and keep local news free, become a member!

Comment policy


  1. The management company does not know why she was evicted, and they do not know where the building is located. That’s some management company. She has an excellent case for a lawsuit.

  2. $75,000.00 in unpaid rent, yet it is always the fault of the “greedy” landlord. Who gives these “politicians” the right to judge without a fair trial? How are they making statements without knowing all the facts???
    Shame on a society that rallies the masses for popular sentiment as opposed to law and order. Shame for trying to take the apartment from the landlord without paying the value thereof.

  3. Do you think this woman would of been in this about for so long if she owed over $75,000 in rent. Please. The management company did not even know the real reason why this woman was evicted

  4. Agreed Michelle. That is the nonsense these “management companies” come up with to intimidate, harass and illegal evict tenants. Meanwhile our tax paying dollars are paying for their wives and children to collect food stamps and section 8, fraudulently taking advantage of the system and tax payers dollars.

    Shame on some if the ignorant comments displayed here. Im sure it is coming from an elitist, new to brooklyn, I feel entitled because i am paying $3,000 for my 1 bedroom apartment, yuppie perspective.

    Final thought, Matthew Eugene does nothing straight up fake and fraud. He is just luck to have a great amount of support from the French speaking community. Sorry to see him re-elected.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here