Newkirk Plaza is Looking to Get Private Security After a String of Robberies and a Decline in Police Presence

Newkirk Plaza sits above a popular subway station, seeing 10,000s of visitors per day. Some of the merchants complained that recent robberies have left commuters feeling unsafe. (Katie Herchenroeder/Bklyner)

The oldest outdoor shopping plaza in America wants to hire private security as an increase in crime and a decrease of community policing shakes the idyllic center of Victorian Flatbush.

Newkirk Plaza is known for its stores, some – like Leon’s Barber Shop – have been in the same business for over a century, and active subway station, serving B and Q lines and an average 10,000 riders on weekdays. It is a busy plaza that has, in recent months, seen a string of robberies. 

Michael Terry, owner of Smoke Shop & Vape, used his own cameras to identify a robbery after hours 2 months ago; an employee of Liberty Chemists, was held at gunpoint as a robber stole 300 dollars from the register and 100 from his pocket last month; and a Plaza Wireless employee was assaulted a few weeks ago. 

“Unfortunately, [police] keep saying Newkirk Plaza doesn’t have that high of a crime rate, but I beg to differ on that,” Newkirk Plaza Merchant Association President Javi Saez said. 

Javier Saez, known as Javi, owns the Almac Hardware store and knows just about everything about the history of the plaza. Merchants have been coming to him with more complaints lately about the state of safety in the area. He also runs the Newkirk Merchants Association and has been working on getting increased security for months. (Katie Herchenroeder/Bklyner)

Worried about its security and the safety of its customers, the plaza association is teaming up with local groups like the West Midwood Neighborhood Association and Flatbush Development Corporation to fund a daily patrol for the area. With the recent show of support of Council Member Dr. Mathieu Eugene at a late October meeting, the groups are calling private security firms to get cost estimates and solve what Saez called an “epidemic.” On average, a posted officer could cost them a few thousand dollars, split between the organizations and the council member. 

Council Member Eugene arrived to the talk at a plaza staple: Don Burrito. “You’re doing a wonderful job identifying the issues impacting your community,” he said, continuing, “you hardworking people should feel safe.” NYPD was invited but did not attend.

The plaza was not always without security. 

Over a decade ago, E, who didn’t want to give her full name due to her prevalence in the community, remembers a time when she felt safe at any hour of the day. 

P.O. Frank Hennessy served as Newkirk Plaza’s community officer more than a decade ago before he died responding to a call in the area. The plaza now features a plaque in his honor. (Katie Herchenroeder/Bklyner)

The difference, she said, can be explained by a lack of a posted officer who knows the community. The plaza has seen an array of community patrollers from the 70th precinct until a few years ago, most beloved being Francis Hennessy, who died in 2006. “When officer Hennessy was there, God rest his soul, we had a much more peaceful feel.”

Since then, the New York Police Department has repeatedly denied the need for a full-time community officer, according to Saez. Instead, the 70th Precinct provides two community officers who are meant to patrol the plaza every hour. Saez said there are sometimes days between visits. 

The police precinct judges allocation by crime statistics, which Saez says are not sufficient because of a lack of reporting.  The NYPD did not respond to repeated requests for comment over a two week period. 

Javier Saez’s office is complete with a security camera display and a two-way mirror. He hopes that private security personnel will help discourage shoplifters at his hardware store. (Katie HerchenroederBklyner)

Because of this shift in police presence, the plaza often only sees law enforcement after a crime has already happened. These interactions can lead to a difficult relationship with the 70th precinct and a general distrust among the community. 

E said that having a stationed person in uniform being consistent, whether it be a P.O. or private security, will help build up a healthier relationship with Midwood’s diverse population. “We lean more towards the darker side. This is why we need someone to build a relationship.” Other local business owners support adding security, but doubt NYPD’s likelihood to serve their shops. 

Newkirk Pharmacist Nancy Behny laughed, “They never catch anybody.” She said that one time the police did not help her and her daughter until three hours after their initial call about a stolen phone. 

Behny’s now used to solving crime in house, largely ignoring small offenses like stealing candy, and hoping nothing worse happens. “I don’t make a big fuss out of it,” she said. “It’s not money,” Behny paused, “yet.”

Smoke Shop & Vape was robbed two months ago. Owner Michael Terry saw the incident happening on his personal cameras that he pays for. (Katie Herchenroeder/Bklyner)

In the next couple of weeks, NPMA, Council Member Eugene, and other groups are figuring out how to find the estimated couple thousand dollars a month for private security. Eugene said he could provide some funding once given a detailed plan, but did not specify if merchants and affiliated community members will still pay a fee. 

Sitting in his office, equipped with security cameras and a two-way mirror, NPMA President Saez said, “Once in a blue moon doesn’t cut it. We need consistency.”

share this story

Katie Herchenroeder

Katie is a freelance journalist who is studying International Journalism at The Craig Newmark Graduate School of Journalism. She focuses her writing on international culture and communication, women’s rights, and other systems of power. Throughout her reporting, she has found a passion for defining the ways we apply value to human life and what people have to say about it. Indiana born, Arizona raised, and New York City living, Katie is thrifty and curious.


  1. All I remember is cops stopping kids on some stop and frisk bs. I ounce saw the same cops hide in the station after gun shots.

  2. For those who haven’t seen Newkirk Plaza, it is a small one block shopping strip where the train runs slightly below street level in the middle with stores on both sides; the entrance to the subway is in the middle. Since DeBlasio tied the hands of the police, the area of Newkirk Plaza and the train station has become less safe. Police never patrol outside the station or even on the platform; rather, once a week, there are several transit cops standing by the booth with a table in a public relations stunt for safety, while crime is being committed by scoundrels within 100 feet of the station entrance. There are quality of life issues too – bums and homeless lie on the benches both day and night, men urinate in public, there is poor lighting for those walking from the station to the nearby streets and there is a constant presence of a wheelchair bound man on drugs with artificial legs who panhandles and blasts obnoxious music in front of stores and is never confronted by the transit police or even the police of the 70 pct. probably because he’s black. Teenagers who routinely sell candy to raise money for school events or teams have become physically aggressive with shoppers and are never stopped by cops, who appear to be very comfortable inside doing their alleged public relations work. In the Bloomberg years, police would have flooded the area in plain clothing and cleaned up the area in a matter of a few days. With DeBlasio and Cuomo, its look the other way and if those aren’t happy with being crime victims, they should leave town. And for those who are stuck in NYC like me, I will be voting to re-elect Donald Trump as President.

  3. What a sad state of affairs. In the 1950’s, my friend & I would walk to the Plaza & lookin the shop windows. We felt perfectly safe and happy to be outdoors.

  4. I have lived in the area for about 13 years and although the area is going through genifrication, police presence has disappeared. I have recently retired and frequent the plaza more often during the day and I notice drug attics, drunks and homeless people . I want to feel comfortable and safe in my neighborhood. Why do we have to spend private money to get security. Where are the police when you need them,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *