Here’s Your Thanksgiving Pie Plan: Where To Order Delicious Pies In Time For The Big Day

Here’s Your Thanksgiving Pie Plan: Where To Order Delicious Pies In Time For The Big Day
Ginger Cookie Pumpkin
Ginger Cookie Pumpkin Pie. (Photo via The Good Batch)

Thanksgiving is all about its savory eats, but what would that holiday meal be without a table full of delicious pies? If you’re running short on time, or got skipped over when the baking genes were handed out, our neighborhood bakeries are ready to round out this year’s Turkey Day feast.


Buttermilk Bakeshop
339 7th Avenue (between 9th and 10th Streets), 347-689-4376
Deadline for Orders: Friday, November 18. Pickups may be scheduled until 7pm on Wednesday, November 23.
Pies available: Buttermilk Bakeshop has some delectable options on their holiday menu, including classic pumpkin pie ($26), caramel walnut apple crumb ($28), buttermilk pie ($26), nutella pecan pie ($28) and pumpkin cheesecake ($34).

Colson Patisserie
374 9th Street at 6th Avenue, 718-965-6400
Deadline for orders: Wednesday, November 23 before 2:30pm.
Pies available: Colson has traditional favorites like pumpkin and apple, but if you’re looking to branch out a bit, don’t miss their cranberry pecan tart. Desserts range from $30-$40.

Ladybird Bakery
1112 8th Avenue (between 11th and 12th Streets), 718-499-8108
Deadline for orders: Saturday, November 19.
Pies available: Ladybird has just about any kind of pie you can imagine, including double crust apple, apple crumb, dutch apple, apple cranberry, pumpkin, pecan, and chocolate. Small pies are $22, and large pies are $28.

Du Jour Bakery
365 5th Avenue (between 5th and 6th Streets), 347-227-8953
Deadline for orders: Monday, November 21.
Pies available: A variety of pies and other desserts are available. 9″ pies range from $25-$40. You can fill out their order form here.


64b Lafayette Avenue
The adorable corner cafe at Lafayette and Fulton is already busy prepping their ingredients and fillings for Dark Chocolate Pecan Pie and Pumpkin Walnut Oat PIe.
Order by this Sunday, November 20. They will be open from 8am-10:30am on Thanksgiving!

299 Greene Avenue
We always make sure to get a Clementine Bakery pastry wherever we see it throughout Brooklyn, so this autumn, don’t miss bringing one of their pies to the big family gathering. Especially if someone needs vegan-friendly and gluten-free items (add $5 for gluten-free or soy-free requests)!
Their flavors include Apple Crumb ($28), Cherry Lattice ($28), Mixed Berry ($30), Pumpkin ($25), Sweet Potato ($25), Apple Cheddar ($28), and Maple Bacon ($30).
Order ASAP.

767 Fulton Street
Greene Grape Provisions certainly provides, with a full Thanksgiving catering menu available — including a pumpkin pie (gluten-free option available), maple pecan pie, and NY state caramel apple pie in the oven, all $42 each as 9-inch pies.
Order by Sunday, November 20 at 9pm.

455A Myrtle Avenue
There’s a full Thanksgiving catering menu available, but check out those pies! Pumpkin, Pecan Chocolate Chunk, and Coconut Creme on available this year for $40 each.
Order by Monday November, 21.


Sign in or become a Bklyner member to join the conversation.