Where To Buy Your Thanksgiving Pie In Brooklyn
While Thanksgiving may be about savory eats, what would the holiday meal be without a delicious pie or two (or more)?
If you’re running short on time, or don’t have the patience for baking, check out our list of local bakeries ready to help out with your Turkey Day dessert.
Better hurry—the deadlines for orders are fast approaching!
Almondine Bakery
85 Water Street (between Main & Old Dock Streets), DUMBO, 718-797-5026
Deadline for orders: Wednesday, November 22
Pies available: This traditional French bakery is offering up apple, pecan, pumpkin, and tart tatin, all 7″ and $35 each.
Baba Cool
64B Lafayette Avenue (at S Elliott Place), Fort Greene, 347-689-2344
Deadline for orders: Tuesday, November 21
Pies available: This cafe will be offering a 9″ pumpkin pie with oatmeal cookie crust and a 9″ pecan pie with a filo crust. ($32 each)
The Blue Stove
415 Graham Avenue (between Frost & Withers Streets), Williamsburg, 718-766-7419
Deadline for orders: Thursday, November 16 at 9pm
Pies available: Along with traditional apple ($37) and pumpkin ($35), this tiny pie shop is offering apple cardamom crumb ($37), raspberry-plum with pecan crumble ($37), molasses rum pecan pie ($35), and bittersweet chocolate mousse ($32). Hurry, their deadline for orders is tonight!
Butter & Scotch
818 Franklin Avenue (between Eastern Parkway & Union Street), Crown Heights, 347-350-8899
Deadline for orders: Saturday, November 18
Pies available: Classic apple, whiskey peanut butter apple, pumpkin sweet potato, s’mores, bourbon ginger pecan, and key lime are on offer, all 10″ and $40 each.
Buttermilk Bakeshop
260 5th Avenue (between 9th and 10th Streets), Park Slope, 347-987-3941
Deadline for Orders: Sunday, November 19. Pickups may be scheduled until 8pm on Wednesday, November 22.
Pies available: Buttermilk Bakeshop has some delectable options on their holiday menu, including classic pumpkin pie ($26), buttermilk pie ($26), caramel apple walnut ($28), cranberry apple crumb ($28), nutella pecan pie ($28) and classic pecan ($26).
Clementine Bakery
299 Greene Avenue (at Classon Avenue), Clinton Hill, 718-483-8788
Deadline for orders: Monday, November 20
Pies available: Flavors include apple crumb ($28), cherry lattice ($28), mixed berry ($30), pumpkin ($25), sweet potato ($25), apple cheddar ($28), and maple pecan ($30). Vegan-friendly and gluten-free options are available for an additional $5.
Colson Patisserie
374 9th Street (at 6th Avenue), Park Slope, 718-965-6400 or 253 36th Street, Sunset Park, 347.637.6676
Deadline for orders: Sunday, November 19
Pies available: Both locations are offering a chocolate pecan tart, a spiced pumpkin tart, or a poached pear and almond tart for $28 each.
Daly Pie
665 Vanderbilt Avenue (between Prospect & Park Place), Prospect Heights, 347-425-9251
Deadline for orders: Sunday, November 19
Pies available: This pie shop has lots of offerings including apple ($30), pumpkin ($35), chocolate bourbon pecan ($35), vegan apple ($35), and gluten-free ($35-$38) options too!
Der Pioneer
737 Church Avenue (at E 8th Street), Kensington, 347-435-0132
Deadline for orders: The restaurant will be taking orders from Saturday, November 18 through Tuesday November 21.
Pies available: Der Pioneer is offering a Thanksgiving supper for pick-up as well as 9″ pies in apple, pecan, and pumpkin ($28 each).
Du Jour Bakery
365 5th Avenue (between 5th and 6th Streets), Park Slope, 347-227-8953
Deadline for orders: Monday, November 20
Pies available: A variety of pies and other desserts are available. 9″ pies come in pumpkin ($30), sweet potato ($30), pecan ($35), bittersweet chocolate pecan ($38), honey crisp apple ($30), apple-cranberry almond crumble ($30), and blueberry buttermilk chess pie ($30). Gluten-free pies are also available. You can complete the order form here.
Four and Twenty Blackbirds
439 Third Avenue (between 7th and 8th Streets), Gowanus, 718-499-2917 and Pie Counter + Bar at 634 Dean Street (between Carlton & Vanderbilt Avenues), Prospect Heights, 347-350-5110
Deadline for orders: ASAP – Wednesday pre-orders are already booked but you can still place an order for Tuesday or Thursday.
Pies available: Options include salty honey, brown butter pumpkin, salted caramel apple, and bittersweet chocolate pecan ($42 each). The Gowanus and Prospect Heights locations will be open from 8am to 12pm on Thanksgiving Day.
The Good Batch
936 Fulton Street (at St James Place), Clinton Hill, 718-622-4000
Deadline for orders: Monday, November 20
Pies available: Two options include apple crumb or ginger cookie pumpkin pie. Both are 9″ and $32 each.
The Greene Grape
767 Fulton Street (between S Portland Avenue & S Oxford Street), Fort Greene, 718-233-2700
Deadline for orders: Sunday, November 19
Pies available: The Greene Grape offers a full Thanksgiving catering menu — including a pumpkin pie, maple pecan pie, and local apple and salted caramel apple pie, all 9″ and $32 each.
Ladybird Bakery
1112 8th Avenue (between 11th and 12th Streets), Park Slope, 718-499-8108
Deadline for orders: Friday, November 17
Pies available: Ladybird has just about any kind of pie you can imagine, including double crust apple, apple crumb, dutch apple, apple cranberry, buttermilk chess, chocolate pecan, fall medley, pumpkin, and pecan. Small (6″) pies are $24 and large (10″) pies are $30.
Lord’s Bakery
2135 Nostrand Avenue (between Flatbush Avenue and Glenwood Road), Flatbush, 718-434-9551
Deadline for orders: walk-in only—pies will be pre-baked, boxed, and ready to purchase
Pies available: Lord’s Bakery will be open from 6am to 7pm on Thanksgiving Day with pie options including apple, blueberry, cherry, pecan, pumpkin, and sweet potato. Prices range from $7.50 for 8″ pies and $12.50 for 10″ pies!
Mia’s Bakery
139 Smith Street (between Dean & Bergen Streets), Boerum Hill, 347-987-3194
Deadline for orders: Tuesday, November 21
Pies available: So many pies! Check out Mia’s Bakery’s options above.
Mrs. Maxwell’s Bakery
2700 Atlantic Avenue (between Vermont & Wyona Streets), East New York, 718-498-2200 or 718-345-7400
Deadline for orders: Wednesday, November 22
Pies available: Choose from apple, blueberry, cherry, coconut custard, lemon merengue, peach crumb, sweet potato, and more ($15 each). The shop will be open on Thanksgiving Day from 8am to 5pm and will have pies baked and available to purchase.
One Girl Cookies
68 Dean Street (between Smith Street & Boerum Place), Cobble Hill; 33 Main Street (corner of Water Street), DUMBO; Industry City Food Hall, 254 36th Street, Suites 106 & 107, Sunset Park; 212-675-4996
Deadline for orders: Tuesday, November 21 by 5pm
Pies available: More than just cookies, this bakery is offering apple, maple pecan, and pumpkin pies, all 9″ and $34 each. Their Cobble Hill and DUMBO locations will be open on Thanksgiving Day from 9am to 2pm.
Peck’s
455A Myrtle Avenue (between Waverly & Washington Avenues), Clinton Hill, 347-689-4969
Deadline for orders: Monday, November, 20
Pies available: Peck’s offers a full Thanksgiving catering menu — including pumpkin and cranberry apple pies ($40 each). They’ll be open on Thanksgiving Day from 7:30am to 12pm.
Pels Pie Co.
446 Rogers Avenue (between Lincoln Road and Lefferts Avenue), Prospect-Lefferts Gardens, 347-350-5906
Deadline for orders: Tuesday, November 21
Pies available: Get renowned homemade pies including country apple, black bottom pumpkin, grapefruit honey lavender, and fig buttermilk ($30 each). Pel’s will be open until 12pm on Thanksgiving Day with a limited number of pies and pastries available on a first-come-first-serve basis.
Pie Corps
77 Driggs Avenue (at Monitor Street), Greenpoint, 929-250-2045
Deadline for orders: Monday, November 20
Pies available: This Greenpoint shop is offering 10″ pies in pumpkin, chocolate pumpkin, apple crumb with raspberry caramel, coconut custard, and so many more ($38 each).
Stolle Bakery Cafe
231 Brighton Beach Avenue (at Brighton 1st Place), Brighton Beach, 855-800-3131
Pies available: Stolle offers savory and sweet pies, with dessert options including apple, cranberry, mixed berry, plum, raspberry, and more. Order online or stop by their shop.
What did we miss? Write in your favorite local spot for Thanksgiving pies in the comments below.
