15 Shops In Brooklyn Where You Can Still Order A Thanksgiving Pie

15 Shops In Brooklyn Where You Can Still Order A Thanksgiving Pie

Thanksgiving is right around the corner! Check out our list below of local bakeries that are still accepting orders for your Turkey Day pie(s).

Almondine Bakery
85 Water Street (between Main & Old Dock Streets), DUMBO, 718-797-5026
Pies available: Classic apple, pecan, pumpkin, and tarte tatin ($40 each). Call or stop in the shop to place your order.

Butter & Scotch
818 Franklin Avenue (between Eastern Parkway & Union Street), Crown Heights, 347-350-8899
Pies available: Classic Apple, Bourbon Ginger Pecan, Key Lime, S’mores, Sweet Potato Pumpkin, and Pie Roulette are on offer, all 10″ and $40 each. Deadline for orders is Monday, November 19.

Buttermilk Bakeshop
260 5th Avenue (between 9th & 10th Streets), Park Slope, 347-987-3941
Pies available: Classic Pumpkin Pie ($30), Buttermilk Pie ($30), Caramel Apple Walnut ($34), Cranberry Apple Crumb ($30), Nutella Pecan Pie ($32) and Classic Pecan ($30). Deadline for orders is Sunday, November 18.

Clementine Cafe & Bakery
395 Classon Avenue (between Clifton Place & Greene Avenue), Clinton Hill, 718-483-8788
Pies available: Flavors include Apple Cheddar ($28), Apple Crumb ($28), Cherry Lattice ($28), Maple Pecan ($30), Mixed Berry ($30), Pumpkin ($25), and Sweet Potato ($25). Gluten-free options are available for an additional $5. Order here.

Colson Patisserie
374 9th Street (at 6th Avenue), Park Slope, 718-965-6400 or Industry City, 253 36th Street (between 2nd & 3rd Avenues), Sunset Park, 347-637-6676
Pies available: Both locations are offering Normandy Calvados Apple Tart, Pumpkin Tart, Poached Pear Almond Tart, and Chocolate Pecan Pie ($42 each). Pick-ups at the Industry City location need to be made by 3pm on Wednesday, November 21. Order online here.

Du Jour Bakery
365 5th Avenue (between 5th & 6th Streets), Park Slope, 347-227-8953
Pies available: 9″ pies come in Apple-Cranberry Cinnamon Crumble ($30), Bittersweet Chocolate Pecan ($38), Blueberry Buttermilk Chess Pie ($30), Honey Crisp Apple ($30), Pecan ($35), Pumpkin ($30), and Sweet Potato ($30). Gluten-free pies are also available for an additional $7. You can complete the order form here.

Four and Twenty Blackbirds
439 Third Avenue (between 7th & 8th Streets), Gowanus, 718-499-2917 and Pie Counter + Bar at 634 Dean Street (between Carlton & Vanderbilt Avenues), Prospect Heights, 347-350-5110
Pies available: Options include Bittersweet Chocolate Pecan, Brown Butter Pumpkin, Salted Caramel Apple, and Salty Honey ($42 each). The Gowanus and Prospect Heights locations will be open until 12pm on Thanksgiving Day. Place your order here.

The Good Batch
936 Fulton Street (at St James Place), Clinton Hill, 718-622-4000
Pies available: Apple Crumble, Brown Butter Pumpkin, and Chocolate Bourbon Pecan ($32 each). Click here to order or visit the shop.

The Greene Grape
767 Fulton Street (between S Portland Avenue & S Oxford Street), Fort Greene, 718-233-2700
Pies available: The Greene Grape offers a full Thanksgiving catering menu — including a Classic Pumpkin Pie, Local Apple Crumb Pie, and Maple Pecan Pie. All pies are 9″ and $34 each. Order here.

Ladybird Bakery
1112 8th Avenue (between 11th & 12th Streets), Park Slope, 718-499-8108
Pies available: Ladybird has just about any kind of pie you can imagine, including Apple Cranberry, Apple Crumb, Double Crust Apple, Dutch Apple, Buttermilk Chess, Chocolate Pecan, Fall Medley, and Pumpkin. Small (6″) pies are $26 and large (10″) pies are $32. Order here.

Marlow & Daughters
95 Broadway (between Bedford Avenue & Berry Street), Williamsburg, 718-388-5700
Pies available: Marlow & Daughters is offering a full Thanksgiving menu including four pie options — Chocolate Chess Pie with Hawaiian Sea Salt ($42), Empire State Apple Pie ($40), Maple Bourbon Pecan Pie ($42), and Pumpkin Pie with Pepita Praline ($40). The shop will be open from 10am to 2pm on Thanksgiving Day. Click here to order.

Mia’s Bakery
139 Smith Street (between Dean & Bergen Streets), Boerum Hill, 347-987-3194
Pies available: Mia’s Bakery has a dozen options including: Apple Crumb (8″ for $21.95, 10″ for $25); Banana Cream ($27); Blueberry (8″ for $21.95, 10″ for $25); Chocolate Cream ($27); Coconut ($25); Sweet Potato ($25); and Triple Berry (8″ for $21.95, 10″ for $25). Click here to order.

Pels Pie Co.
446 Rogers Avenue (between Lincoln Road & Lefferts Avenue), Prospect-Lefferts Gardens, 347-350-5906
Pies available: Options include Country Apple, Black Bottom Pumpkin, Fig Buttermilk, Grapefruit Honey Lavender, Peach, and many more ($30 each). Pel’s will be open from 9am to 5pm on Thanksgiving Day. Choose your pie here.

Pie Corps
77 Driggs Avenue (at Monitor Street), Greenpoint, 929-250-2045
Pies available: This Greenpoint shop’s holiday pie options include Brown Butter Pumpkin, Dutch Apple Crumble with Rosemary Caramel (their signature), Maple Bourbon Chocolate Pecan, Nantucket Cranberry, and many more ($38 each). Call to order or email them at piecorpsnyc@gmail.com.

Wythe Hotel, 80 Wythe Avenue (between N11th & N12th Streets), Williamsburg, 718-460-8004
Pies available: Reynard Thanksgiving pies are 9″ and come in Apple Crumb, Chocolate Pecan, and Pumpkin ($40 each). Click here to order. Deadline for orders is Friday, November 16.


Sign in or become a Bklyner member to join the conversation.