‘The voting line was so long that I just got here’: Brooklyn residents, officials talk state voting reform


BROOKLYN HEIGHTS – Details from a Brooklyn hearing on Election Day voting problems could help form the basis for state electoral reform.

“Once the new election committees are named in both houses, we’ll be sending links from today’s testimony to every member, so they can hear what you’re talking about,” said Susan Lerner, executive director of Common Cause New York, a progressive watchdog group.

Lerner said the First Unitarian Congregational Society in Brooklyn Heights was a prime location for Tuesday night’s hearing because Brooklyn has the most voters of any borough. There were just shy of 1.6 million registered voters in Brooklyn as of Nov. 1, 2018, ahead of Queens’ 1.2 million. 

“The problems tend to surface here more than in any other area,” Lerner said.

State Senator Brian Kavanagh speaks. Orla McCaffrey/Bklyner

New York State Senator Brian Kavanagh, who represents north-western Brooklyn and lower Manhattan, told the nearly 100 attendees that now is the time for election reform.

“People have begun to realize that the way we run elections is a big factor in the outcome,” Kavanagh said.

The first Democratic majority in the state senate in 10 years will play a key role in reform next year, Kavanagh said. Early voting and automatic voter registration are among the most-needed changes in New York, he said.

City council member Brad Lander distinguished between state reforms and those needed at the city level.

“Achieving a New York City Board of Elections that runs professionally is also important and will take a broader set of changes,” Lander said.

Roberta Intrater of Ditmas Park said the voting machine she used on Election Day was terrible. “In this day and age, I couldn’t even imagine where you found those things.” Photo by Orla McCaffrey/Bklyner

Those changes include creating a clearer accountability system for election officials and finding a new way to select the 10 Board of Elections commissioners, he said. Currently, commissioners are nominated by the political party of each borough.

“It’s not simple to figure out how to do, but Board of Elections reform is on the long-term agenda,” Lander said.

Voting difficulties across the city were well-documented on Election Day. Broken ballot scanners were common, and voters reported waiting for hours. There were misleading instructions. By the early afternoon, City Council Speaker Corey Johnson called for the resignation of Michael Ryan, executive director of the Board of Elections.

Poor interactions with poll workers were raised by a number of people in attendance.

One man said a worker had accused him of voter fraud when his signature didn’t match the one in the poll book. Another said a worker accidentally handed him two ballots and told him he could only vote for members of a single party.

Naomi Wolf of Ditmas Park worked the polls during the primaries this year and said poll worker training has room for improvement.

“When they’re training you, you don’t know which role it’s for,” she said. “The test is open-book and 20 questions long. But many questions I had weren’t answered in the book.”

Poll workers could be better trained with more funding and revamped instruction, said New York State Assemblywoman Jo Anne Simon.

“It’s a very big issue,” Simon said. “The city Board of Elections is very underfunded. They don’t pay people very much. That’s on us to fight for in city and state budget.”

Tuesday’s hearing was hosted by Let NY Vote, a coalition of advocacy groups working to make New York state’s voting laws more progressive. Its policy proposals include: early voting, automatic voter registration, a timely way to change parties and pre-registration for 16- and 17-year-olds.


Jumaane Williams, who represents the 45th city council district in eastern Brooklyn, arrived near the end of the discussion.

“Sorry, everyone,” he said. “The voting line was so long that I just got here.”

Election laws have been slow to change because many elected officials don’t want more people voting, Williams said.

“My seat is not more important than the people I’m representing,” he said. “New York State claims to be progressive. We’re one of the worst for voting; that’s ridiculous. It makes no sense, and we have the ability to change it.”

Never miss the day's stories!

This story is free to read thanks to the generous support from readers like you. To support independent local journalism and keep local news free, become a member!

Comment policy


  1. Early voting is guaranteed to lead to fraud. This will allow for multiple voting in different districts and states, stolen ballots being submitted and permit the dead to vote. What standards would be used for automatic registration: all those with driver’s licenses? This will grant non-citizens the right to vote, something which is illegal, except in California. Lander and Williams once again show how much common sense both lack. To have the right to vote in a democracy is something that majority of people across the globe lack. The right to vote is something people should be proud of and if we have to wait on line, so what? We go the store, we wait on line. People want to go the movies in Lander’s district, we wait in line to first buy the ticket and then another line to get into the theater. We wait in line at train stations, bus stops and airports. Early voting is just an excuse by Democrats to gain power. The US Constitution states that election day is the first Tuesday after the first Monday in November and does not permit early voting. Exceptions are made for soldiers, those traveling on election day and those who physically can’t travel, but they need to show proof. I would suggest that Lander and Williams start reading our constitution but since these two have show total disrespect for our country by refusing to stand for our Pledge of Allegiance, who can expect them to study the constitution?


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here