Southern Brooklyn

Coney Island Gardeners Gain Small Victory Against Planned Amphitheater

The garden, before and after bulldozing. Source:
The garden, before and after bulldozing. Source:

The Coney Island Boardwalk Community Garden received an agreement from the city to stop construction of the amphitheater on the site of their recently destroyed garden. Construction will be postponed until June 10 when the Kings County Supreme Court will hear the case.

The local garden community lost their greens, cats and chickens last year during a midnight raid by the city that left the whole garden completely destroyed. The destruction happened only 10 days after former Borough President Marty Markowitz received permission from the city to begin construction on the amphitheater. The proposed 5,099-seat Seaside Park and Community Arts Center was to be the permanent home of Markowitz’s summer concert series and was seen as a personal project of the beep’s, even after Community Board 13 voted the theater down.

The displaced gardeners had filed the lawsuit in March.

The land the garden sits on is city-owned, and is where seating for the amphitheater will be located. It’s next to the Childs Restaurant building, which will be the stage – and which has not yet been purchased by the city.

Some information on the two conflicting claims, via our earlier reports:

[The] outraged gardeners say that the city failed to do its due diligence, and that the West 22nd Street greenspace was legally a New York City park and the group had an agreement with the city to operate the garden, which should have at least delayed the demolition.

The city, though, previously claimed that the garden was decommissioned as a park in 2004, Brownstoner points out. The group says the city never told them that and let them continue to operate for years, according to NY1.

Comment policy


  1. […] Brooklyn is getting an Ace Hotel [Commercial Observer] A tour of Greenpoint history [Greenpointers] Coney Island gardeners put a brief halt to amphitheater construction [Sheepshead Bites] What can New York learn about designing a city from Copenhagen? [Untapped […]

  2. No comments? A midnight raid wipes out a local garden in the middle of the night and no one sees a problem with this? All the tax dollars spent to keep that beach from washing away and no comments? The therapy a garden provides is priceless. It is therapy for those gardening, those watching, eating the fruits and the pride it gives a whole community.. A suffering community.
    Put your blankets on the VERY expensive beach,

Comments are closed.